从分形图片用Box counting方法计算分形维数的一个例子

2024-02-04 01:18

本文主要是介绍从分形图片用Box counting方法计算分形维数的一个例子,希望对大家解决编程问题提供一定的参考价值,需要的开发者们随着小编来一起学习吧!

点击打开链接

l dimension of natural objects from digital images

up vote 42 down vote favorite
18

This is a useful topic. A college physics lab, medical diagnostics, urban growth, etc. - there is a lot of applications. On this site by Paul Bourke about Google Earth fractals we can get a high resolution images (in this post they are low res - import from source for experiments). For example, around Lake Nasser in Egypt:

img = Import["http://paulbourke.net/fractals/googleearth/egypt2.jpg"]

Lake Nasser boundary

The simplest method I know is Box Counting Method which has a lot of shortcomings. We start from extracting the boundary - which is the fractal object:

{Binarize[img], iEdge = EdgeDetect[Binarize[img]]}

outline of Lake Nasser

Now we could partition image into boxes and see how many boxes have at least 1 white pixel. This is a very rudimentary implementation:

MinS = Floor[Min[ImageDimensions[iEdge]]/2];
data = ParallelTable[{1/size, Total[Sign /@ (Total[#, 2] & /@ (ImageData /@ Flatten[ImagePartition[iEdge, size]]))]}, {size, 10, MinS/2, 10}];

From this the slope is 1.69415 which is a fractal dimension that makes sense

line = Fit[Log[data], {1, x}, x]

13.0276 + 1.69415 x

Plot[line, {x, -6, -2}, Epilog -> Point[Log[FDL]], PlotStyle -> Red, Frame -> True, Axes -> False]

plot of fractal dimension line

Benchmark: if I run this on high res of Koch snowflake i get something like ~ 1.3 with more exact number being 4/log 3 ≈ 1.26186.

Question: can we improve or go beyond the above box counting method?

All approaches are acceptable if they find fractal dimension from any image of natural fractal.

share edit flag
 
2
 
You have a lot of programs in mathematica to measure fractal dimensions and multi fractal spectrum of an image in the book: Fractal Geography, Andre Dauphine, Wiley, 2012 See the book on the Wolfram Mathematica | Books or Amazon ![enter image description here](wolfram.com/books/profile.cgi?id=8108)–   Dauphine  Oct 16 '12 at 9:32 

You can still use box count, but doing it smarter :)

Counting boxes with at least 1 white pixel from ImagePartition can be done more efficiently usingIntegral Image, a technique used by Viola-Jones (2004) in their now popular face recognition framework. For a mathematical motivation (and proof), Viola and Jones point to this source.

Actually, someone already asked about a Mathematica implementation here.

What Integral Image allows you to do is to compute efficiently the total mass of any rectangle in an image. So, you can define the following:

IntegralImage[d_] := Map[Accumulate, d, {0, 1}];
data = ImageData[ColorConvert[iEdge, "Grayscale"]]; (* iEdge: your snowflake image *)
ii = IntegralImage[data];

Then, the mass (white content) of a region, is

(* PixelCount: total mass in region delimited by two corner points, given ii, the IntegralImage *)
PixelCount[ii_, {p0x_, p0y_}, {p1x_, p1y_}] := ii[[p1x, p1y]] + ii[[p0x, p0y]] - ii[[p1x, p0y]] - ii[[p0x, p1y]];

So, instead of partitioning the image using ImagePartition, you can get a list of all the boxes of a given size by

PartitionBoxes[{rows_, cols_}, size_] := Transpose /@ Tuples[{Partition[Range[1, rows, size], 2, 1], Partition[Range[1, cols, size], 2, 1]}];

If you apply PixelCount to above, as in your algorithm, you should have the same data but calculated faster.

PixelCountsAtSize[{rows_, cols_}, ii_, size_] :=((PixelCount [ii, #1, #2] &) @@ # &) /@ PartitionBoxes[{rows, cols}, size];

Following your approach here, we should then do

fractalDimensionData = Table[{1/size, Total[Sign /@ PixelCountsAtSize[Dimensions[ii], ii, size]]}, {size, 3, Floor[Min[Dimensions[ii]]/10]}];
line = Fit[Log[fractalDimensionData], {1, x}, x]Out:= 10.4414 + 1.27104 x

which is very close to the actual fractal dimension of the snowflake (which I used as input).

Two things to note. Because this is faster, I dared to generate the table at box size 3. Also, unlike ImagePartition, my partition boxes are all of the same size and therefore, it excludes uneven boxes at the edges. So, instead of doing minSize/2 as you did, I put minSize/10 - excluding bigger and misleading values for big boxes.

Hope this helps.

Update

Just ran the algorithm starting with 2 and got this 10.4371 + 1.27008 x. And starting with 1 is 10.4332 + 1.26919 x, much better. Of course, it takes longer but still under or around 1 min for your snowflake image.

Update 2

And finally, for your image from Google Earth (eqypt2.jpg) the output is (starting at 1-pixel boxes)

12.1578 + 1.47597 x

It ran in 43.5 secs in my laptop. Using ParallelTable is faster: around 28 secs.

share edit flag
 
 
There isn't a "snowflake" image. All three images come from the same object (and I guess the fractal dimension should be the same for all of them) –   belisarius  Dec 23 '13 at 21:03
upvote
  flag
@belisarius, the PO published a Koch snowflake image as Benchmark (see last part of post) and that's the one I used. I called it 'snowflake' for short. On the other hand, this is still a numerical procedure, so the numbers will be different depending on approximation. The Update2 refers to the eqypt2.jpg image, also made available by the PO, as he asked for an improvement suitable for real-life images. –   caya  Dec 23 '13 at 22:40
 
sorry, I missed that link. Thanks –   belisarius  Dec 24 '13 at 0:05
 
+1 This is very neat @caya, thank you! I will wait "a bit" hoping that someone can implement things likewavelet multi-fractals or similar. –   Vitaliy Kaurov  Feb 14 at 20:02 
 
@VitaliyKaurov, glad you liked it. Note that Viola & Jones rightly pointed out a link between integral imageand Haar wavelet basis in their paper; although this wasn't explored further. It is unclear to me the link between the paper you mentioned and fractal dimension, but certainly worth reading as I am interested in these kind of problems. Cheers. –   caya  Feb 16 at 12:40

这篇关于从分形图片用Box counting方法计算分形维数的一个例子的文章就介绍到这儿,希望我们推荐的文章对编程师们有所帮助!



http://www.chinasem.cn/article/675982

相关文章

SQL Server配置管理器无法打开的四种解决方法

《SQLServer配置管理器无法打开的四种解决方法》本文总结了SQLServer配置管理器无法打开的四种解决方法,文中通过图文示例介绍的非常详细,对大家的学习或者工作具有一定的参考学习价值,需要的... 目录方法一:桌面图标进入方法二:运行窗口进入检查版本号对照表php方法三:查找文件路径方法四:检查 S

MyBatis-Plus 中 nested() 与 and() 方法详解(最佳实践场景)

《MyBatis-Plus中nested()与and()方法详解(最佳实践场景)》在MyBatis-Plus的条件构造器中,nested()和and()都是用于构建复杂查询条件的关键方法,但... 目录MyBATis-Plus 中nested()与and()方法详解一、核心区别对比二、方法详解1.and()

golang中reflect包的常用方法

《golang中reflect包的常用方法》Go反射reflect包提供类型和值方法,用于获取类型信息、访问字段、调用方法等,文中通过示例代码介绍的非常详细,对大家的学习或者工作具有一定的参考学习价值... 目录reflect包方法总结类型 (Type) 方法值 (Value) 方法reflect包方法总结

C# 比较两个list 之间元素差异的常用方法

《C#比较两个list之间元素差异的常用方法》:本文主要介绍C#比较两个list之间元素差异,本文通过实例代码给大家介绍的非常详细,对大家的学习或工作具有一定的参考借鉴价值,需要的朋友参考下吧... 目录1. 使用Except方法2. 使用Except的逆操作3. 使用LINQ的Join,GroupJoin

MySQL查询JSON数组字段包含特定字符串的方法

《MySQL查询JSON数组字段包含特定字符串的方法》在MySQL数据库中,当某个字段存储的是JSON数组,需要查询数组中包含特定字符串的记录时传统的LIKE语句无法直接使用,下面小编就为大家介绍两种... 目录问题背景解决方案对比1. 精确匹配方案(推荐)2. 模糊匹配方案参数化查询示例使用场景建议性能优

关于集合与数组转换实现方法

《关于集合与数组转换实现方法》:本文主要介绍关于集合与数组转换实现方法,具有很好的参考价值,希望对大家有所帮助,如有错误或未考虑完全的地方,望不吝赐教... 目录1、Arrays.asList()1.1、方法作用1.2、内部实现1.3、修改元素的影响1.4、注意事项2、list.toArray()2.1、方

Python中注释使用方法举例详解

《Python中注释使用方法举例详解》在Python编程语言中注释是必不可少的一部分,它有助于提高代码的可读性和维护性,:本文主要介绍Python中注释使用方法的相关资料,需要的朋友可以参考下... 目录一、前言二、什么是注释?示例:三、单行注释语法:以 China编程# 开头,后面的内容为注释内容示例:示例:四

一文详解Git中分支本地和远程删除的方法

《一文详解Git中分支本地和远程删除的方法》在使用Git进行版本控制的过程中,我们会创建多个分支来进行不同功能的开发,这就容易涉及到如何正确地删除本地分支和远程分支,下面我们就来看看相关的实现方法吧... 目录技术背景实现步骤删除本地分支删除远程www.chinasem.cn分支同步删除信息到其他机器示例步骤

在Golang中实现定时任务的几种高效方法

《在Golang中实现定时任务的几种高效方法》本文将详细介绍在Golang中实现定时任务的几种高效方法,包括time包中的Ticker和Timer、第三方库cron的使用,以及基于channel和go... 目录背景介绍目的和范围预期读者文档结构概述术语表核心概念与联系故事引入核心概念解释核心概念之间的关系

在Linux终端中统计非二进制文件行数的实现方法

《在Linux终端中统计非二进制文件行数的实现方法》在Linux系统中,有时需要统计非二进制文件(如CSV、TXT文件)的行数,而不希望手动打开文件进行查看,例如,在处理大型日志文件、数据文件时,了解... 目录在linux终端中统计非二进制文件的行数技术背景实现步骤1. 使用wc命令2. 使用grep命令